The Starlink gold rush and the problem with spreadsheets
I’ve been selling advertising to travellers for 35 years. And I still wake up every morning excited about introducing new brands to people who are going somewhere. It’s been quite a journey.
When we started, it was all about the inflight magazine. Every magazine publisher looked at the airline business and thought, how hard can it be? Captive audience, millions of readers, guaranteed distribution. Easy money.
One by one, they arrived. And one by one, they left, battered and bruised with their tail between their legs. It really was never easy, we just made it look that way. 35 years later, our magazines remain in the sky despite the naysayers that said print was dying in 2008. To be fair, the media landscape has changed beyond recognition, and so have we.
Today, through ReachTV, we’re entertaining millions of passengers across America’s airports with live sport, news and entertainment. We’re reaching people while they’re waiting to board, when they’ve got time on their hands and are genuinely engaged. We broadcast across the globe, with Business Traveller TV. And then they get on the plane.
That’s where things have become really interesting.
The arrival of free inflight WiFi has opened up an extraordinary opportunity. This year alone, we have been able to provide over 30 million free WiFi sessions, paid for by our advertising partners. Thirty million passengers getting something genuinely valuable for free, with brands picking up the bill. It’s a terrific proposition. And we’ve become rather good at it. Apparently, according to the world’s smartest consultants, we have no idea what we are doing.
Welcome to the latest airline gold rush
With Starlink joining the connectivity to aircraft brigade, the opportunity is enormous. Potentially another billion connected passenger journeys, and a completely new digital advertising landscape. And along come the consultants. McKinsey, Boston Consulting Group, Accenture and the rest of the spreadsheet brigade, with their extraordinary forecasts and grand visions of airline retail media becoming the next Amazon, Meta or Google. I am wondering what they are smoking over there? Billions and billions of dollars just waiting to be collected.
I’ve heard versions of these presentations for years. Different slides, different technology, same enormous numbers. So much money left on the table. The issue is they do not understand the airline advertising business. And there’s always one question I like to ask. Who’s actually going to buy it? Which brands have these enormous budgets sitting around waiting to spend them on airline WiFi? Who is going to persuade them? What are they going to stop to buy this? Who is going to build the relationships, create the campaigns, explain the audience, manage the delivery and make sure the advertisers come back? And that’s a lot of campaigns to traffic and track.
Oh, don’t worry, Simon. The computers will do it all.
Of course they will. Because that’s exactly what a premium airline passenger needs. They’ve paid thousands of pounds for their seat, they’re enjoying a glass of fine wine in 11C at 35,000 feet, and up pops an advert for toenail fungus treatment. Followed by a dose of the latest GLP-1 weight-loss injection, and then some great advice how to deal with a fatty liver, dating issues and a new range of premium saucepans.
What a magical brand experience.
It’s remarkable how quickly the conversation goes quiet when you start asking who the advertisers actually are.
Passengers don’t buy advertising
Stuart Adamson, founder of Platform 195, recently wrote an excellent piece about the increasingly ridiculous projections being presented to airlines. He made one observation that should be printed on the wall of every airline boardroom:
“The problem is that passengers don’t buy advertising, advertisers do.” Spot on.
You can have 30 million passengers, 100 million passengers or a billion connected journeys. It means absolutely nothing unless you have relevant brands willing to spend money reaching those people. The bit our friends with the calculators are missing, airlines already have commercial agreements with hotels, car hire companies, insurance providers, E-sims, parking and other partners. Some of those agreements prevent them from selling advertising to competing brands. We’ve navigated this for three decades.
So before you start multiplying your passenger numbers by some imaginary advertising value, perhaps work out who you’re actually allowed to sell to. It’s a rather important detail. And one that doesn’t always fit neatly into an Excel spreadsheet. Not every problem can be solved within an Excel spreadsheet said me, too many times.
Over the years, some airports and airlines have decided to bring their advertising businesses in-house. They soon discover if the phone stops ringing how tough it is, and that the revenues promised by their advisers bear little resemblance to the money that actually arrives in the bank.
I had exactly this conversation with a rather large US carrier. I told them I thought they were making a mistake. But when someone puts a sufficiently enormous number in front of an executive, it’s very difficult for them not to believe it. The initiative has been shelved, despite two amazing showings at Cannes. And now I fear we’re about to see the same movie all over again, this time starring Starlink.
Handing your audience to the open internet
But there’s something even more worrying than getting the advertising numbers wrong.
Airlines are about to give away one of the most valuable things they’ve spent decades building. Their own audience.
Think about it.
An airline has a wonderful ecosystem. From the moment someone starts thinking about a trip, to booking their ticket, checking in, arriving at the airport, boarding the aircraft and eventually reaching their destination. Every one of those moments is an opportunity to build a relationship. For decades, the inflight magazine was a beautiful part of that relationship.
It wasn’t just a place for advertising. It was where airlines told their stories. Where they introduced passengers to new destinations, celebrated their people, showcased their networks and explained why flying with them was something special. You could discover that your airline flew to a city you’d never considered visiting. Read about a new route, a new aircraft, a wonderful restaurant or an extraordinary hotel. It was story telling of the finest inspiration, entertainment and education, all wrapped up in the airline’s own brand.
Then came the inflight entertainment portal. Another fantastic opportunity to introduce passengers to the airline, its network, its loyalty programme and everything that made it different. And now?
You board, connect, and disappear into the World Wide Web. Gone, straight to WhatsApp, Instagram, Netflix, TikTok, emails or whatever else you were doing before you left home.
The airline has spent a fortune getting you connected, only to hand your attention to somebody else. You might not even discover where else that airline flies. You won’t see the beautiful destinations it serves, the wonderful new cabins it’s invested in or the reasons you should choose it for your next journey. And that is an extraordinary missed opportunity. Some airlines have already lost much of that storytelling through the disappearance of their magazines. Now they risk losing the next generation of engagement through their entertainment portals. We delete more emails than we read.
They’re so busy trying to work out how much money they can make from passengers that they’ve forgotten how much value there is in talking to them. And once someone disappears into the internet, getting them back is going to be incredibly difficult.
Why you need to protect the passenger experience
You’ve built a beautiful shop window. Why would you encourage everyone to walk straight past it? For years, airlines have spent fortunes creating wonderful onboard experiences. Beautifully designed cabins, thousands of hours of films and television, and award-winning wine lists curated by some of the world’s finest sommeliers.
At Business Traveller, we’ve spent decades recognising the airlines that get these things right. And now that carefully curated experience is competing with six hours of uninterrupted doomscrolling.
Imagine spending millions creating an award-winning inflight entertainment experience, only for your passengers to spend the entire flight watching videos of somebody else’s cat.
Or worse, answering work emails.
The airline isn’t just competing with another airline any more. It’s competing with the entire internet.
And if you think a banner advert or an irritating interstitial is going to persuade someone to stop pushing the connect button, you are mistaken. They just wanna continue watching their favourite series or replying to their messages, good luck. You’ve just spent hundreds of millions of dollars connecting your fleet to the world’s most powerful entertainment and communication network.
Never let the logic kill the magic
Now, after reading this, you might assume, I don't believe in this medium, oh please don’t misunderstand me. I think free inflight WiFi is one of the most exciting developments in aviation for decades. I love it. Our advertisers love it. Passengers certainly love it.
We’ve proved that brands will pay to connect passengers. Thirty million sessions don’t happen by accident. And there is a huge amount of money to be made for everyone involved.
But the opportunity isn’t simply to sell a few million more impressions. It’s to build something genuinely valuable around the entire passenger journey. Before they fly. At the airport. Onboard. And when they arrive. It’s about creating a reason for brands to become part of the experience, rather than simply interrupting it. It’s about understanding the moment, the mindset and the customer.
And it’s about helping the airline tell its own story at the same time. A good advertising partnership should make the passenger experience better, not worse. Free WiFi is a brilliant example. The passenger gets something valuable. The advertiser reaches a highly desirable audience. And the airline gets a commercial return while making its customers happy.
Everybody wins. That’s a real business.
Computers are brilliant at many things. But when it comes to selling advertising inventory, they have a remarkable talent for doing one thing: driving prices down. They turn something special into a commodity. They take a premium audience and put it into the same auction as a million other websites. And before you know it, the extraordinary audience you’ve spent billions creating is being sold for pennies. An airline passenger is not just another anonymous internet user. They’re travelling somewhere. They have a destination, a purpose, a spending mindset and often a considerable amount of disposable income.
That makes them valuable. But only if you know how to explain that value to advertisers.
And only if you protect it. Stuart Adamson made another point that really resonated with me. The worst thing you can do to a promising media business is give it a forecast it was never going to achieve. It can be performing brilliantly and still be judged a failure. I’ve watched that happen. I’ve seen businesses generate genuinely impressive revenues, only to be considered disappointing because someone in a boardroom had promised three times as much.
And that is exactly what worries me about the current Starlink gold rush. Not that airline WiFi advertising won’t work, It absolutely does to today, and will continue to do so if its managed sensibly and we don't just turn on the pipes and fill it with irrelevant rubbish. There is a reason, why today a page in an inflight magazine is so much more expensive than one in a bookshelf.
It’s that overenthusiastic executives, encouraged by consultants with wildly optimistic forecasts, will destroy its value before it has the chance to become a genuinely meaningful revenue stream. If you end up being rational and logical, you and your competitors end up in the same place. Sometimes you need imagination. Sometimes you need experience. And sometimes you need somebody who has actually spent 35 years selling advertising to tell you that your beautiful spreadsheet is complete nonsense.
So here’s my offer
If you’re an airline investing in Starlink, or any other inflight connectivity platform, and you’re thinking about how to generate advertising revenue, give myself or Ric Stockfis a call.
We’ll tell you what we believe you can realistically achieve. We’ll explain what advertisers actually want, what they’ll pay for, and what will make them come back. We’ll also talk about how you protect that wonderful ecosystem you’ve spent decades creating, rather than handing your passengers over to the internet without even telling them where you fly.
And I promise you, the opportunity is exciting. Just not quite as exciting as the consultants would have you believe. We’ve spent 35 years learning how to sell advertising to travellers. We’ve survived every new technology, every new platform and every bright-eyed newcomer who thought this business was easy. We survived Covid, wars and fuel spikes galore. We’re still here, still growing and still very excited about what is coming next. And I’d love to see airlines build something extraordinary with this new opportunity.
I just hope they don’t blow it. Because the real magic isn’t in connecting a billion passengers to the internet.
It’s in giving advertisers a billion good reasons to reach them, while giving those passengers a billion good reasons to fly with you again.

